My goal is to read 100 books this year. Given the reading year I had in 2011 I know the goal is borderline ridiculous but I've had plenty of years in my life when I did read 100 so I figured, why not "swing for the fences" this year? If I come up short of the 100 I know for sure I will read more than if I set a low goal and don't push myself forward. I'm sure you can all look forward to hearing me ruminate throughout the year about how far behind I am in meeting my goal!
So, here's the first one...99 more to go (she says optimistically)!
A Thousand Lives by Julia Scheeres is the story of The People's Church led by Jim Jones and the fate they met when they moved to Guyana and attempted to set up their version of a socialist utopia in the jungle. Jim Jones and his congregation had their church in San Francisco, California for many years so when the story broke that over 900 of the church members had killed themselves in a mass suicide in the jungles of a faraway country, it was front page news in the San Francisco Bay Area where I grew up. I can remember poring over the articles and asking myself how something like this could have happened and more importantly I kept asking myself WHY?
I always thought that Jim Jones was a well-intentioned minister who fell prey to drug abuse and began having more outlandish views at the end of his life. Ms. Scheeres makes the case that he was corrupt from the beginning. He began declaring himself to be God, even in the early years of his ministry. However, he did espouse a powerful message of peaceful co-existence of races during a time in the U.S when there was still segregation in churches. Many African Americans were drawn to his ministry and to his message of racial harmony as were others who looked at the world around them and wanted to make it a better place.
Jim Jones was a savvy leader. He understood he needed to be tied to the political powers in his community. He managed to get appointed to be the head of the San Francisco Housing Authority and rubbed elbows with the movers and shakers in city hall. His proximity to power allowed him to perpetrate a great deal of fraud on his congregation and get away with it. There were always complaints about the church but since he was friends with the local power brokers, they were always stamped out before they became a problem.
The people who followed Jim Jones and joined his church wanted to help others, they were searching for racial equality, and many were lonely and looking to belong. Many were those that lived on the fringes of society like ex cons, the mentally ill, the elderly. They craved love and acceptance and The People's Church gave it to them. When Jones suggested that they should go to a faraway country and set up a different kind of society where all were equal, they couldn't wait to leave.
By the time Jones moved his most faithful followers to Guyana to set up a socialist utopia, many were in too deep to become disillusioned. He controlled many aspects of their lives including who would raise their children, who they could have sex with, etc. He convinced them that the rest of the world was against them and they had to stand together or fall together. When they arrived in Guyana he confiscated their money and passports, thereby making them virtual prisoners. They were isolated from their families at home, had no way of leaving the commune and may not have even realized that they wanted to. If anyone gave any sign of trouble or started to disagree he would threaten them or simply drug them so they would become more compliant.
Doesn't it all sound crazy or unreal? Unfortunately, it really happened. 900+ intelligent, good minded, idealistic people put themselves in a position to be controlled by one megalomaniac with a God complex and a small inner circle that had their own mental health issues they were probably acting on. In the end, they all committed suicide. Many had to be forced but most did it on their own and that is the part that is the most unbelievable.
I couldn't wait to read this book when I saw it at the library. I couldn't wait to get answers to questions that I had been wondering about for over 30 years. While I think the book does an excellent job of telling WHAT happened I do feel like it fell short of explaining the WHY. Maybe it is because the WHY can never be known or understood so I can't really fault the author for that. The author listened to hundreds of audiotapes of Jim Jones and the church and went through thousands of documents so the book is well-researched and thorough. I enjoyed learning more about Jim Jones and the people who followed his ministry and ultimately sacrificed their lives for it and can recommend the book to anyone who is curious about this event and wants to know more about it.

I think this is exactly why you and I are so obsessed with true crime, which is what this is, right? I want to understand WHY. If I can't get that answer I still want as much information as I can get my hands on. I have this book and intend to read it this year. Excellent review!
ReplyDeleteI'm not sure we'll ever know the why since all the people involved are dead. I well remember the Jonestown Massacre and look forward to this book. Good luck with your goal!
ReplyDeleteWow, sounds fabulous! I'm going to have to look for it. Jonestown is sort of forgotten about these days but things like this can and do happen. Good luck with your challenge!
ReplyDeleteGreat review! This sounds like a fantastic book of non-fiction to read. I have the author's first book, Jesusland, but haven't read it yet.
ReplyDeleteGood luck with your goal!
That was a terrible event. This is a wonderful review of a thoughtful and intelligent book. You ask the tough questions, though we'll probably never know the answers.
ReplyDeleteBest of luck with your reading goal--you can do it!!
Psychologically speaking, one reason dictators do rather well is that they reproduce the conditions, familiar to many people, of stern parenting. We grow up under what feel like arbitrary rules, imposed dogmatically, and in many ways, the child in that environment is very conscious of his or herself, being forever pushed up against limits both internal and external. Oddly enough, we are quite in touch with ourselves under repressive conditions. It suits a lot of people not to be free - in fact, most of us will have made ourselves 'slaves' to some arbitrary and unnecessary rule or task. Or even something bigger than that, an unhappy life, an abusive job, a negative view of ourselves. It's very common to want to be 'controlled' by something we 'can't change'. So cults and dictators find easy prey amongst people whose characters tend in this direction. Alas! We are manipulated so easily, really.
ReplyDeleteThis sounds like a great one to start you off in the right direction for 2012. Have fun Kathleen.
ReplyDeleteI found this one fascinating, too, Kathleen - I was very surprised to read how intentional his plans were, how hard he worked to control these people, to get beyond the bounds of accountability to the law, etc. Such a tragedy- the story of the last days- the children who were killed - it just broke my heart.
ReplyDeleteGood luck with your 100 books goal this year Kathleen :)
ReplyDeleteI remember reading about this extensively when it happened; it just seemed so surreal.
I think what you said about not getting a better sense of why may relate to the fact that, as you point out, so many of his followers were of such vulnerable populations.
I will look for this one in the library; it's one I think I'd like to read, but would probably not want to own.
I remember this clearly. I remember seeing photos of the all the bodies in a news magazine and being so shocked that it could happen. This kind of thing just seems to alien to me.
ReplyDeleteBest of luck on the 100 books!
I remember when this happened--such a shocking thing and hard to understand how it happened. It sounds like an interesting book--even if you end up with as many questions as when you started! Good luck reaching 100 books--what a nice thought of so many books ahead of you!
ReplyDeleteOh my goodness, I do think I recall hearing about this. It is truly unbelievable that he was able to persuade so many to commit suicide.
ReplyDeleteThis sounds like an interesting true crime book. Great review. I do like well researched books.
I try to read 100 books a year, but have yet to manage it. I'm giving it another go this year as well.
Good luck!
Dear Boarding in my Forties:
ReplyDeleteCan I interest you in reviewing my new work of fiction, UGLY TO START WITH, published last month by West Virginia University Press?
I've won awards for my writing. If you write me back at johnmcummings@aol.com, I'll send you some information.
I would be grateful to hear from you.
Thank you.
Kindly,
John Michael Cummings
900 hundred people? It is amazing how this could have happened and not too long ago when you think about it right?
ReplyDeleteGood luck with your reading goal Kathleen! I hope you get to your 100 books and maybe more :) I keep thinking I'll get to 100 but somehow every year I feel like I'm reading less. Yikes.
It does kind of answer why though - prey on the needy/desperate/trusting, pump them up so they worship you, and they will do whatever you ask. Now, why you would ask them for their lives and take your own in the process is another why I could explore forever. Got any more good reads to delve into that? Looking forward to seeing your reading journey this year :0)
ReplyDeleteafter reading your profile, i've just got to suggest another book for 2012. check out "An Uncertain Age" at www.ulricahume.com
ReplyDeleteI could never read the whole book, but your review has made me curious. The why of horrifying events almost is never truly known, which is part of what makes them so terrifying, right?
ReplyDeleteSandy, I think this is definitely why I love true crime. I've just read another few that I will be talking about so I am thinking you will have a few more to add to your list!
ReplyDeleteKathy at BermudaOnion: Thanks Kathy! I' ve read 5 so far so I am behind where I should be but reading at a good pace.
ReplyDeleteMarie: I am amazed at how quickly this story faded out. You never hear about it anymore except for here in the San Francisco Bay Area where it gets brought up every once in awhile.
ReplyDeleteVasily: I definitely want to read Jesus Land too!
ReplyDeleteds: I hate that we'll never understand it but I guess all of the people who would have the answers are now dead.
ReplyDeleteLitlove: What you say makes perfect sense and it is also frightening because I have a realization that things like this can happen again and again.
ReplyDeleteThanks Diane! So far I have finished 5 books so I feel like I am on a bit of a roll.
ReplyDeleteCarrie: The part about the children was when I had to put the book down for awhile. It was so devastating for me to think of parents killing their children and then getting ready to die themselves and some of the older children protested and that just killed me to think about it.
ReplyDeleteTheBookGirl: I've read 5 so far so for me I am on a bit of a roll. I seem to be stuck on non-fiction at the moment so hopefully I will start reading something a bit lighter in the coming weeks!
ReplyDeleteJenners: The whole thing really seems unreal and I can't believe it happened. The sad thing is that it could probably happen again.
ReplyDeleteDanielle: The book was definitely a good read even though I had more question than answers at the end of it. I'm excited for all of my reads this year and hope to meet my goal!
ReplyDeleteNaida: The whole thing is so difficult to fathom and figure out the reasons why.
ReplyDeleteIliana: It is impossible for me to imagine so many people dying and for nothing!
ReplyDeleteThe Bumbles (Molly): I've been on a non-fiction role lately. Stay tuned for future posts that are in a similar vein.
ReplyDeleteStacybuckeye: You are so right about our not understanding the why is what makes these events even more frightening.
ReplyDelete